I think it should be more up to the userbase to vote for what they think is best. This makes a lot of sense to me especially in the case of the incomplete submission; if it's really that bad, it won't win anyway.
I think the gay Luigi one is kind of a troll submission but I can't decide for myself just how offensive it is. Maybe a lot of gay people might find it funny even. I can't say for sure, especially since I'm not gay myself. But really, that's more of the administration's job, I'd say.
That aside, I don't believe I've said this to you yet: welcome to the back forums and it's nice to see you contributing, Black Boo
Looks like someone has issues. Grow the hell up will ya, its not even -that- offensive. What are you, some kind of representation for LGBT+ folk arent ya?