+- MFGG Forums (https://forums.mfgg.net)
+-- Forum: MFGG (https://forums.mfgg.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Development Showcase (https://forums.mfgg.net/forumdisplay.php?fid=8)
+--- Thread: WIP Rachel the Yoshi Girl (/showthread.php?tid=149)
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Pedigree - 01-23-2018
(01-23-2018, 08:05 PM)Evil Yoshi Toes Wrote:she's a problem too but she had more clothes on than the plant girl(01-23-2018, 01:50 PM)Pedigree Wrote: Does the Piranha Plant boss really need a bra and extremely tight shorts???
Like I don't want to censor your creativity but this IS NOT the place for "sexy" Piranha Plant Girls.
Why are piranha plants an issue but not the Yoshi? The entire game is extremely sexual.
It seems to have been decided that the game is censored enough for the forums, but I don't think it should go on the main site as the audience there is quite young and a sexual game has no place among a young audience.
I'm not crazy about the designs in this game, but the sprite is well done. Is that a whip in her hand?
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Knuckles - 01-25-2018
Personally I find the main focus of your game unappealing and it overshadows everything that you are doing. Sharing your fetish to everyone is really gross. No matter how fun the gameplay may be or how nice the graphics may get, there is no way I would play a game like this.
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Saltman - 01-25-2018
(01-25-2018, 01:04 AM)Ugandan Knuckles Wrote: Personally I find the main focus of your game unappealing and it overshadows everything that you are doing. Sharing your fetish to everyone is really gross. No matter how fun the gameplay may be or how nice the graphics may get, there is no way I would play a game like this.
You can probably end up missing great games in the future for a reason like this, y'know? This one is sure more original than a hello clone at least.
You could also specify what's so "gross" about it.
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Evil Yoshi Toes - 01-25-2018
(01-25-2018, 01:40 AM)Saltman Wrote:(01-25-2018, 01:04 AM)Ugandan Knuckles Wrote: Personally I find the main focus of your game unappealing and it overshadows everything that you are doing. Sharing your fetish to everyone is really gross. No matter how fun the gameplay may be or how nice the graphics may get, there is no way I would play a game like this.
You can probably end up missing great games in the future for a reason like this, y'know? This one is sure more original than a hello clone at least.
You could also specify what's so "gross" about it.
Well, not everyone is going to want to play a game designed to turn people on. That said, there isn't necessarily anything wrong with making a fetish game, even if it's not something I'd ever play, but I don't think MFGG is the place for such games.
If someone were to make a game featuring a scantily clad Princess Peach sucking on bananas it would not be allowed on MFGG because it is clearly meant to provide sexual arousal. So why would a game like this be allowed? Simply because it is a less common thing to be aroused by? It still is made for the same purpose, so why would it be treated any differently?
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Saltman - 01-25-2018
(01-25-2018, 02:41 AM)Evil Yoshi Toes Wrote:(01-25-2018, 01:40 AM)Saltman Wrote:(01-25-2018, 01:04 AM)Ugandan Knuckles Wrote: Personally I find the main focus of your game unappealing and it overshadows everything that you are doing. Sharing your fetish to everyone is really gross. No matter how fun the gameplay may be or how nice the graphics may get, there is no way I would play a game like this.
You can probably end up missing great games in the future for a reason like this, y'know? This one is sure more original than a hello clone at least.
You could also specify what's so "gross" about it.
Well, not everyone is going to want to play a game designed to turn people on. That said, there isn't necessarily anything wrong with making a fetish game, even if it's not something I'd ever play, but I don't think MFGG is the place for such games.
If someone were to make a game featuring a scantily clad Princess Peach sucking on bananas it would not be allowed on MFGG because it is clearly meant to provide sexual arousal. So why would a game like this be allowed? Simply because it is a less common thing to be aroused by? It still is made for the same purpose, so why would it be treated any differently?
A game with Peach sucking Bananas does mean... something.
This game though, I just don't get where's the big problem. The characters may be sexified, but that alone doesn't make it a game that wants to give people that. I haven't seen Rachel doing anything with Bananas, if you know what I mean.
For now, the characters are just girls with bras and shorts.
Only things I'd criticize are their big bellies. I don't get why do all of them have to be fat while having slim limbs. Maybe that's part of what's making people feel "uncomfortable" with their design, I think.
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Knuckles - 01-25-2018
(01-25-2018, 01:40 AM)Saltman Wrote: You can probably end up missing great games in the future for a reason like this, y'know? This one is sure more original than a hello clone at least.
You could also specify what's so "gross" about it.
Do you know what vore is? It isn't an openly accepted fetish and didn't expect something depraved like this to be on this forum. With a game revolving around a fetish that makes me feel gross I don't think I'll be missing out on anything great.
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Nessa - 01-25-2018
then post in a thread about something u /do/ like cause nobody cares what u think
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Evil Yoshi Toes - 01-25-2018
(01-25-2018, 12:21 PM)sl0shy Wrote: then post in a thread about something u /do/ like cause nobody cares what u think
People are allowed to to discuss what they think should be allowed, but I understand if you don't want your topic flooded with posts that don't necessarily help with the game itself despite concerning the game's content. Perhaps we had better make a new topic to discuss this issue.
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Nessa - 01-25-2018
(01-25-2018, 01:10 PM)Evil Yoshi Toes Wrote: you don't want your topic flooded with posts that don't necessarily help with the game itselfthats p much it rigt there
(01-25-2018, 01:10 PM)Evil Yoshi Toes Wrote: Perhaps we had better make a new topic to discuss this issue.thats what i been saying for the 3 last pages but i guess ppl prefer to use sum1's devv thread as a dupming ground for there concerns
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Pedigree - 01-25-2018
The theme of your game is an on-topic concern to have.
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Nessa - 01-25-2018
but arguing over mfgg rules here is not. take it to suggestions
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - Evil Yoshi Toes - 01-25-2018
I made a new topic devoted to this issue in order to keep this topic free of debate over the rules. Out of respect for sl0shy I think we should keep our discussion regarding the matter there.
RE: Rachel the Yoshi Girl - PixelatedIvan - 02-03-2018
This is basically a war topic at this point.
EDIT: not criticizing the creator and/or game