MFGG Forums
  • Home
  • Members
  • Help
  • Search
MFGG Main Site MFGG Forums MFGG Suggestions v
« Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
A Critique of Icon Links
MFGG Forums MFGG Suggestions v
« Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
A Critique of Icon Links
MFGG Forums MFGG Suggestions v
« Previous 1 2 3 4 5 Next »
A Critique of Icon Links
Mark All Posts Read Today's Posts

A Critique of Icon Links
United States Cap'n Coconuts
Koopa
Members
Submitter Super Reviewer Sprite Comp Top 5 Minigame Comp Top 5 Music Comp Runner-Up Music Comp Top 5 Skull Badge Golden Skull Badge Game of the Month Winner NCFC Contributor Secret Santa Popeyes Badge MFGG Awards 2014 Winner MFGG Awards 2015 Winner
#1
12-02-2017, 12:03 AM
If you're looking at this post on the thread page, you will see a paper airplane icon at the bottom of it. You may click it to send a PM to me, but how would you know that the airplane icon links to that without mousing over it? This kind of link delves into what is called "mystery meat navigation," which has been criticized for favoring aesthetics over user-friendliness.

Besides that, the heavy use of icons may not be very user-friendly, especially those who aren't computer savvy. Icon understanding is based on previous user experience, and thus the current theme's heavy use of wordless icons may confuse people with limited internet experience.

What I'd suggest is replacing the airplane with something more obvious (even just "PM" as a link would be an improvement) and placing immediately visible text beside the icons (for PC users at least).
[-] The following 1 user Likes Cap'n Coconuts's post:1 user Likes Cap'n Coconuts's post
  ↳ Miles
United States Action Lemon Away
Hammer Bro
Members
Submitter Iso Collab Contributor Sprite Comp Top 5 Minigame Comp Winner Minigame Comp Top 5 Drawing Comp Runner-Up Drawing Comp Top 5 Secret Santa Holiday Tree Good Citizen
#2
12-02-2017, 12:07 AM
I completely agree with this. Those little icon confuse me on what they do.

  ↳
Kritter Away
.
Members
Kritter Badge Big Help Submitter Iso Collab Contributor Sprite Comp Runner-Up Sprite Comp Top 5 Music Comp Winner Music Comp Runner-Up Music Comp Top 5 Monthly Mayhem Winner Egg Hunter Skull Badge E3 Bingo Game of the Month Winner NCFC Contributor Holiday Tree KFC Badge MFGG 17th Anniversary MFGG 18th Anniversary MFGG Awards 2004 Winner MFGG Awards 2006 Winner MFGG Awards 2014 Winner
#3
12-02-2017, 12:33 AM
Almost all of the current forum icons were default with the skin and I just never got around to changing them. I'd be happy to change it with something text-based.

  ↳
United States VinnyVideo
Can't have an avatar without a Shy-Guy
Site Developer
Main Site Moderator Site Developer/Webmasters Wiki SysOp Big Help Submitter Super Reviewer (2) Wiki Contributor Sprite Comp Runner-Up Minigame Comp Winner Minigame Comp Runner-Up Minigame Comp Top 5 (3) Music Comp Winner Music Comp Runner-Up Music Comp Top 5 (2) Drawing Comp Top 5 Game of the Month Winner NCFC Contributor (4) Secret Santa (5) MFGG 17th Anniversary MFGG 18th Anniversary MFGG 19th Anniversary Ye Olde MFGGe Retro Game Jam Participant MFGG Awards 2010 Winner MFGG Awards 2011 Winner MFGG Awards 2012 Winner MFGG Awards 2013 Winner MFGG Awards 2014 Winner MFGG Awards 2015 Winner MFGG Awards 2017 Winner (3) MFGG Awards 2019 Winner MFGG Awards 2024 Winner
#4
12-02-2017, 10:16 AM
Some icon links are pretty much universal - almost anyone who's used a computer knows that a magnifying glass means search/find, and that a printer icon lets you print. However, a lot of icon links are not so universal and can be confusing. As noted in the article in the original post, icon links tend to work better on mobile devices than in a desktop environment.
Course clear! You got a card.

[Image: CourseClear.gif]


  ↳
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »

Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)



  • View a Printable Version
Forum Jump:

Mario Fan Games Galaxy - Powered by MyBB | MFGG Staff | Contact Us

Linear Mode
Threaded Mode