02-16-2018, 07:00 PM
I listened to the new stuff, and the old stuff too since I'm just now seeing the topic.
My music criticism is like my pixel art criticism: I'm no expert and can't articulate how I feel about it super well, but I feel like I can generally spot when something is on the good, bad, or meh side of the spectrum.
A pattern I notice is that they kinda feel repetitive to me, though I'd wait on a better opinion before going out of your way to fix this.
The drums on Minus Galaxy might be a little overwhelming, also. The melody is pretty neat, though also pretty short.
If I had to pick three favorites I'd probably say:
- SeinQuest Supermarket. I like stripped-back instrumentals, and this is one of em. Also the eccentric horns are cool.
- Untitled Famitracker Song. It's longer and the songcraft seems to stand out to me compared to the others. It's got a longer melody, which is nice. Also I don't know how intentional this is, but some of the chiptune-y noise in the background sounds like something you'd hear from a crazy hip hop instrumental or something.
- Mega Man X3 - Dr Light Capsule remix. I guess technically you didn't write the melody, but you did make it something other than a lonely synth and I think it works.
![[Image: GGyaUXO.png]](http://i.imgur.com/GGyaUXO.png)
![[Image: ggc0JQ0.png]](http://i.imgur.com/ggc0JQ0.png)
![[Image: d7OJc4b.png]](http://i.imgur.com/d7OJc4b.png)
Bibby Team
My music criticism is like my pixel art criticism: I'm no expert and can't articulate how I feel about it super well, but I feel like I can generally spot when something is on the good, bad, or meh side of the spectrum.
A pattern I notice is that they kinda feel repetitive to me, though I'd wait on a better opinion before going out of your way to fix this.
The drums on Minus Galaxy might be a little overwhelming, also. The melody is pretty neat, though also pretty short.
If I had to pick three favorites I'd probably say:
- SeinQuest Supermarket. I like stripped-back instrumentals, and this is one of em. Also the eccentric horns are cool.
- Untitled Famitracker Song. It's longer and the songcraft seems to stand out to me compared to the others. It's got a longer melody, which is nice. Also I don't know how intentional this is, but some of the chiptune-y noise in the background sounds like something you'd hear from a crazy hip hop instrumental or something.
- Mega Man X3 - Dr Light Capsule remix. I guess technically you didn't write the melody, but you did make it something other than a lonely synth and I think it works.
Vimimin Wrote:Hylian's day job, little did we know, was saying controversial things on the internet.
Mors Wrote:you fool!!!! you fixed it wrong!!!!
Bibby Team