what's your favorite old fan game?

[LearnintoLurk]

Not my favourite game, but I have a weird soft spot for Paper Mario World. It's a terrible game, but for some reason I always saw it as "So Bad, it's good." It has a decent length to it and you can actually PLAY through it to completion, although I don't know how playable it was before the "Gold Edition" by Yoshiman, as I've only played that one.

For actual quality games, my votes go to Stardust and Super Mario Epic 2. Both of those games showed me how talented the devs on this site were.