Making a second mainsite for non-Mario stuff

[Vitiman]

Agreed with Kritter.

Sister site would just split the community.

Per the OP, "This would not cannibalize the MFGG forums in any way. The "community" link would still point to the MFGG forums - we won't need a separate forum (or a separate Wiki or Discord group) for this."

Plus, either way you spin it, there are probably people who only went to MFGG for Mario content and find an expansion not to their tastes. It's less a matter of "trying to please everybody" and more "thinking what's best for the community in the long term". Kritter certainly raises some good points, but I'm still leaning more towards a sister site - especially since any major changes to MFGG proper would have to wait until LumaSMS enters the foray, while a separate area for non-Mario fangame content could theoretically be built off of anything (although I suspect it would be upgraded to LumaSMS once that's completed).

For a point of comparison, Sonic Retro is still Sonic Retro, and yet it has a separate directory of sorts for Sega as a whole dubbed (as one would expect) "Sega Retro". It's been around for quite a while I believe and it seems to be running just fine and hasn't split the community at large.

Also, full disclosure: I'm the other MFGGer that Hypernova is referring to in his post.